From: Thomas R. Kettler on
In article <hvo9iv$mhs$1(a)news.eternal-september.org>,
"Kyle T. Jones" <KBfoMe(a)realdomain.net> wrote:

> xyzzy wrote:
> > On Jun 21, 10:39 am, "The Ghost Of Edward M. Kennedy" <e...(a)o.com>
> > wrote:
> >> If the US draws 0-0 and England draws 2-2, the advancing team
> >> will be the winner of a RANDOM draw.
> >>
> >> The athleticism involved in a random draw is simply AM-ZING!
> >> The good news is that the odds of England scoring twice is
> >> near absolute zero.
> >>
> >> --Tedward
> >
> > No less random than a shoot-out (IMO)
>
> Settling the most important soccer games in the world with a shoot-out
> at the end absolutely sucks.
>
> However, it's still better than flipping a coin.
>
> Cheers.

Is it worse than the way the NCAA decides BCS Championship Games with
alternating possessions from the opponent's 25-yard line negating many
things a defense can do?
--
Remove blown from email address to reply.
From: The Ghost Of Edward M. Kennedy on
"Kyle T. Jones" <KBfoMe(a)realdomain.net> wrote

>>> If the US draws 0-0 and England draws 2-2, the advancing team
>>> will be the winner of a RANDOM draw.
>>>
>>> The athleticism involved in a random draw is simply AM-ZING!
>>> The good news is that the odds of England scoring twice is
>>> near absolute zero.
>>>
>>> --Tedward
>>
>> No less random than a shoot-out (IMO)
>
> Settling the most important soccer games in the world with a shoot-out at
> the end absolutely sucks.
>
> However, it's still better than flipping a coin.

A cat raping contest would be better than flipping a coin.

--Tedward


From: Kyle T. Jones on
Thomas R. Kettler wrote:
> In article <hvo9iv$mhs$1(a)news.eternal-september.org>,
> "Kyle T. Jones" <KBfoMe(a)realdomain.net> wrote:
>
>> xyzzy wrote:
>>> On Jun 21, 10:39 am, "The Ghost Of Edward M. Kennedy" <e...(a)o.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>> If the US draws 0-0 and England draws 2-2, the advancing team
>>>> will be the winner of a RANDOM draw.
>>>>
>>>> The athleticism involved in a random draw is simply AM-ZING!
>>>> The good news is that the odds of England scoring twice is
>>>> near absolute zero.
>>>>
>>>> --Tedward
>>> No less random than a shoot-out (IMO)
>> Settling the most important soccer games in the world with a shoot-out
>> at the end absolutely sucks.
>>
>> However, it's still better than flipping a coin.
>>
>> Cheers.
>
> Is it worse than the way the NCAA decides BCS Championship Games with
> alternating possessions from the opponent's 25-yard line negating many
> things a defense can do?

Yes.
From: The Ghost Of Edward M. Kennedy on
"Thomas R. Kettler" <tkettler(a)blownfuse.net> wrote

>> >> If the US draws 0-0 and England draws 2-2, the advancing team
>> >> will be the winner of a RANDOM draw.
>> >>
>> >> The athleticism involved in a random draw is simply AM-ZING!
>> >> The good news is that the odds of England scoring twice is
>> >> near absolute zero.
>> >>
>> >> --Tedward
>> >
>> > No less random than a shoot-out (IMO)
>>
>> Settling the most important soccer games in the world with a shoot-out
>> at the end absolutely sucks.
>>
>> However, it's still better than flipping a coin.
>>
>> Cheers.
>
> Is it worse than the way the NCAA decides BCS Championship Games with
> alternating possessions from the opponent's 25-yard line negating many
> things a defense can do?

A shootout is definitely unfair to a counrty with lousy goalies.

--Tedward


From: Thomas R. Kettler on
In article <hvobes$gc9$1(a)news.eternal-september.org>,
"The Ghost Of Edward M. Kennedy" <ei(a)o.com> wrote:

> "Thomas R. Kettler" <tkettler(a)blownfuse.net> wrote
>
> >> >> If the US draws 0-0 and England draws 2-2, the advancing team
> >> >> will be the winner of a RANDOM draw.
> >> >>
> >> >> The athleticism involved in a random draw is simply AM-ZING!
> >> >> The good news is that the odds of England scoring twice is
> >> >> near absolute zero.
> >> >>
> >> >> --Tedward
> >> >
> >> > No less random than a shoot-out (IMO)
> >>
> >> Settling the most important soccer games in the world with a shoot-out
> >> at the end absolutely sucks.
> >>
> >> However, it's still better than flipping a coin.
> >>
> >> Cheers.
> >
> > Is it worse than the way the NCAA decides BCS Championship Games with
> > alternating possessions from the opponent's 25-yard line negating many
> > things a defense can do?
>
> A shootout is definitely unfair to a counrty with lousy goalies.

The NCAA OT system is definitely unfair to a team with a
bend-but-don't-break defense or a team with a lousy place kicker.
--
Remove blown from email address to reply.