From: The Scrutineer on


"milivella" <milivella(a)gmail.com> wrote in message
news:f05bbe28-f4a0-45c4-8e94-c4b3a7f68977(a)q22g2000yqm.googlegroups.com...
> The Scrutineer:
>
>> Pace
>>
>> D R - Marvell Wynne
>
> s*g: 0.59 sum: 0.59 record: 0.73
> s: 1.00 sum: 1.00 record: 0.60
>
>> D C - Thiago Silva
>
> s*g: 0.59 sum: 1.18 record: 1.29
> s: 0.75 sum: 1.75 record: 1.10
>
>> D C - Ivan Cordoba
>
> s*g: 0.70 sum: 1.88 record: 1.77
> s: 0.90 sum: 2.65 record: 1.70
>
>> D L - Gael Clichy
>
> s*g: 0.72 sum: 2.60 record: 2.37
> s: 0.90 sum: 3.55 record: 2.40
>
>> DM - Per Skjelbred
>
> s*g: 0.00 sum: 2.60 record: 3.01
> s: 0.00 sum: 3.55 record: 3.10
>
> Oh damn, after a _pacey_ start another 0-point DM put your score down!
> But you're still ahead of the skill-only record, and you have still
> some hope for the score*greatness ranking... but you have to _run_
> fast to recover the lost ground! (Figures of Speech 101... failed)

No failed pun, a delight in reading!!!, Now that bad selection makes me
wonder what Per actually is judged by your system? Surely not a AM/ C?? Also
if you don't mind, what score would he have been awarded if picked in his
*right* position?

>> DM - Lassana Diarra
>
> s*g: 0.66 sum: 3.26 record: 3.66
> s: 0.80 sum: 4.35 record: 4.05
>
>> AM R - Theo Walcott
>
> s*g: 0.70 sum: 3.96 record: 4.56
> s: 0.95 sum: 5.30 record: 4.75
>
>> AM C - Lionel Messi
>
> s*g: 0.76 sum: 4.72 record: 5.51
> s: 0.80 sum: 6.10 record: 5.65
>
>> AM L - Arjen Robben
>
> s*g: 0.79 sum: 5.51 record: 5.51
> s: 0.90 sum: 7.00 record: 6.65
>
> The second ranking is in your pocket and you're tied for the first...
>
>> ST - Fernando Torres
>
> s*g: 0.77 sum: 6.28 record: 6.22
> s: 0.85 sum: 7.85 record: 7.40
>
> Great! You're on top of both the rankings! Congratulations.
>
> Skill*Greatness

Wohooooo!!! Potentially two more entries!!!

> 6.28 The Scrutineer Pace*
> 6.22 Abubakr Dribbling
> 6.01 Diabolik Agility
> 5.77 Diabolik Technique
> 5.61 Abubakr Long Shots
> 5.44 Futbolmetrix Injury Proneness
> 5.41 Diabolik Passing
> 4.97 The Scrutineer Injury Proneness

First and last, but its always hard going second, especially for a tough
*skill* in injury proneness!!!

> Skill only
> ----------
>
> 7.85 The Scrutineer Pace*
> 7.40 Diabolik Technique
> 7.05 Abubakr Dribbling
> 6.95 Diabolik Passing
> 6.90 DIabolik Agility
> 6.70 The Scrutineer Injury Proneness
> 6.65 Abubakr Long Shots
> 6.60 Futbolmetrix Injury Proneness
>
> * Wynne T.Silva Cordoba Clichy - Skjelbred L.Diarra - Walcott Messi
> Robben - Torres
>
> --
> Cheers
> milivella

From: milivella on
The Scrutineer:

> Now that bad selection makes me
> wonder what Per actually is judged by your system? Surely not a AM/ C??

Yes, central AM! Football Manager guys are not the only ones with this
opinion, though: see e.g.
http://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/tags/per-ciljan-skjelbred/
But a shared error is still an error, of course.

> Also
> if you don't mind, what score would he have been awarded if picked in his
> *right* position?

No problem at all: 0.42 - 0.60

> Wohooooo!!! Potentially two more entries!!!

You can know understand what Bob Beamon felt after his first jump in
1968...

> First and last, but its always hard going second, especially for a tough
> *skill* in injury proneness!!!

Indeed.

--
Cheers
milivella
From: Diabolik on

"milivella" <milivella(a)gmail.com> wrote in message
news:561e6bfd-0610-49c0-adc1-6b7a57cd49ab(a)i21g2000yql.googlegroups.com...
> Diabolik:
>
>> Let me try for Agility:
>>
>> RB: Sergio Ramos
>
> s*g: 0.53 sum: 0.53 record: 0.73
> s: 0.65 sum: 0.65 record: 0.60
>
>> CB: Nesta
>
> s*g: 0.46 sum: 0.99 record: 1.29
> s: 0.55 sum: 1.20 record: 1.10
>
>> CB: Puyol
>
> s*g: 0.64 sum: 1.63 record: 1.77
> s: 0.75 sum: 1.95 record: 1.70
>
>> LB: Philipp Lahm
>
> s*g: 0.72 sum: 2.35 record: 2.37
> s: 0.85 sum: 2.80 record: 2.40
>
>> DM: Cambiasso
>
> s*g: 0.60 sum: 2.95 record: 3.01
> s: 0.70 sum: 3.50 record: 3.10
>
>> DM: Mascherano
>
> s*g: 0.61 sum: 3.56 record: 3.66
> s: 0.70 sum: 4.20 record: 4.05
>
>> AMR: David Silva
>
> s*g: 0.00 sum: 3.56 record: 4.56
> s: 0.00 sum: 4.20 record: 4.75
>
>> AMC: Messi
>
> s*g: 0.90 sum: 4.46 record: 5.51
> s: 0.95 sum: 5.15 record: 5.65
>
>> AML: Robben
>
> s*g: 0.79 sum: 5.25 record: 5.51
> s: 0.90 sum: 6.05 record: 6.65
>
>> S: David Villa
>
> s*g: 0.76 sum: 6.01 record: 6.22
> s: 0.85 sum: 6.90 record: 7.40
>
> A dubious decision strips you of an otherwise sure double win! :(

David Silva? Is he AMC? I should have went for Ronaldo!

> Ranking:
>
> Skill*Greatness
> 6.22 Abubakr Dribbling
> 6.01 Diabolik Agility
> 5.77 Diabolik Technique
> 5.61 Abubakr Long Shots
> 5.44 Futbolmetrix Injury Proneness
> 5.41 Diabolik Passing
> 4.97 The Scrutineer Injury Proneness
>
> Skill only
> 7.40 Diabolik Technique
> 7.05 Abubakr Dribbling
> 6.95 Diabolik Passing
> 6.90 DIabolik Agility
> 6.70 The Scrutineer Injury Proneness
> 6.65 Abubakr Long Shots
> 6.60 Futbolmetrix Injury Proneness
>
> --
> Cheers
> milivella

From: milivella on
Diabolik:

> David Silva? Is he AMC?

C or L, not R. :(

--
Cheers
milivella
From: Mark V. on
On Jul 24, 8:51 am, milivella <milive...(a)gmail.com> wrote:

Someone will beat me at this if they challenge me!

> Loyalty

GK Casillas

RB Gary Neville
CB John Terry
CB Carragher
LB Lahm

DM Gerrard (sort of works in this scheme -- we'll see what FM decides)
DM Albelda

LAM Giggs
AM Totti
RAM Xavi

FW del Piero