From: Futbolmetrix on
A player who wins World Cup Young Player of the Tournament gets 100 bonus
points.

A player who is World Cup topscorer (or joint topscorer) wins 200 bonus
points.

A player who is World Cup Player of the tournament wins 500 bonus points.

(just so that you won't say that this is an ad hominem proposal).

D



From: MH on
Futbolmetrix wrote:
> A player who wins World Cup Young Player of the Tournament gets 100 bonus
> points.

No way. Even though �zil and Khedira deserve that honour more than
M�ller anyway.


>
> A player who is World Cup topscorer (or joint topscorer) wins 200 bonus
> points.

Nope !

>
> A player who is World Cup Player of the tournament wins 500 bonus points.

Certainly not.

These are completely ridiculous suggestions. Fantasy scout is a game
whose results are decided by objective, measurable criteria, and there
should be no influence of the type of committee silly enough to award
Zidane a player of the tournament award twice.
>
> (just so that you won't say that this is an ad hominem proposal).
>
> D
>
>
>
From: Futbolmetrix on
"MH" <MHnospam(a)ucalgary.ca> wrote in message
news:i1anoh$5i6$2(a)news.ucalgary.ca...
> Futbolmetrix wrote:
>> A player who wins World Cup Young Player of the Tournament gets 100 bonus
>> points.
>
> No way. Even though �zil and Khedira deserve that honour more than M�ller
> anyway.

I disagree. Oezil faded badly in Germany's last two competitive games, while
Mueller absence was sorely felt.

>
>>
>> A player who is World Cup topscorer (or joint topscorer) wins 200 bonus
>> points.
>
> Nope !
>
>>
>> A player who is World Cup Player of the tournament wins 500 bonus points.
>
> Certainly not.
>
> These are completely ridiculous suggestions.

They are? Darn! I should have tried to be more subtle...

Come on, MH, give us poor mortals a chance. I've done some subjective
analysis of what I think each one of the players chosen by milivella, you
and me will score, and it's not pretty at all. I would need Joe Hart (the
last of my players likely to get me some points) to record 150 caps to get
even close.

D


From: MH on
Futbolmetrix wrote:
> "MH" <MHnospam(a)ucalgary.ca> wrote in message
> news:i1anoh$5i6$2(a)news.ucalgary.ca...
>> Futbolmetrix wrote:
>>> A player who wins World Cup Young Player of the Tournament gets 100 bonus
>>> points.
>> No way. Even though �zil and Khedira deserve that honour more than M�ller
>> anyway.
>
> I disagree. Oezil faded badly in Germany's last two competitive games, while
> Mueller absence was sorely felt.

Agree M�ller's absence was sorely felt, but that was due to picking the
inept Trochowski as his replacement rather than Marin or Kroos.

>
>>> A player who is World Cup topscorer (or joint topscorer) wins 200 bonus
>>> points.
>> Nope !
>>
>>> A player who is World Cup Player of the tournament wins 500 bonus points.
>> Certainly not.
>>
>> These are completely ridiculous suggestions.
>
> They are? Darn! I should have tried to be more subtle...
>
> Come on, MH, give us poor mortals a chance.

Here he is anti-weaufxing Fantasy scout results !

I've done some subjective
> analysis of what I think each one of the players chosen by milivella, you
> and me will score, and it's not pretty at all. I would need Joe Hart (the
> last of my players likely to get me some points) to record 150 caps to get
> even close.

You are ignoring the large number of duds I have picked.

However, some bonuses today in Khedira's goal, and Tasci's very brief
appearance.

Total number of points I got so far this WC is not that high

�zil 7 + 1
Khedira 7 + 1
Tasci 1

Lloris 3
Valbuena 1

Elia 4 ? (can't remember how many sub appearances he has made)

Mata 1
Martinez 1

Doesn't amount to all that much when divided by the total number of
players.

Enzo's yield on Busquets, Llorente and Otamendi is probably higher.
>


> D
>
>
From: milivella on
Futbolmetrix:

> A player who wins World Cup Young Player of the Tournament gets 100 bonus
> points.
>
> A player who is World Cup topscorer (or joint topscorer) wins 200 bonus
> points.
>
> A player who is World Cup Player of the tournament wins 500 bonus points.
>
> (just so that you won't say that this is an ad hominem proposal).

Agreed. From the 2nd cycle, right? :P

(BTW, I'll compute the updated FS scores and rankings as soon as
possible.)

--
Cheers
milivella