Argentina - Mexico (R)
in [World Football]
|
From: Yo Merito on 28 Jun 2010 12:31 HASM <netnews(a)invalid.com> writes: > Yo Merito <yomerito(a)gawab.com> writes: > >>>> ....because it'd been given. It's against the rules to take back the >>>> call. >>> Not in general. It can't be taken back if play already resumed, but before >>> that it is possible to change one's mind. >> so, what's your take? why do you think he didn't? > > Watch the replay, as soon as the ball goes in, the AR runs up the field > which is the standard signal the goal is good as far as he is concerned, > i.e. he didn't see offside or any other infraction that could invalidate > the goal. The referee was not in position to call offside on his own, so > they have nothing to go with. > > The AR is going to get dinged in his assessment, as he missed a game > changing call, and so will the referee, to a lesser extent, but if they do > change the call based on video evidence, which should not have been shown > in the stadium, they'll get into a lot of trouble to the point that the > game can be protested and, if not during the WC, potentially replayed. > > So they're stuck with the original call as they won't be able to justify > reverting it. Ok, thanks a lot! I am just amazed that most of times I think the refs made a bad offside call, the replay shows I'm wrong. The guys at WC are very good at what they do. Hence the shock at such a wrong decision.
From: Bruce D. Scott on 28 Jun 2010 14:00 Yo Merito (yomerito(a)gawab.com) wrote: : Ok, thanks a lot! : I am just amazed that most of times I think the refs made a bad offside : call, the replay shows I'm wrong. The guys at WC are very good at what : they do. Hence the shock at such a wrong decision. It's a wrong call but it happens... Bayern got a goal like that against Fiorentina, and you can forgive them for saying it matters. In our case it was the 2-1 at the end of the game... we lost down there 3-2 but went through on away goals. -- ciao, Bruce drift wave turbulence: http://www.rzg.mpg.de/~bds/
From: JK on 28 Jun 2010 16:16 Ll�o wrote: > "Sid" <sid(a)invalid_nerte.invalid.invalid_net.invalid> escreveu na mensagem > news:slrni2f6hb.nl.sid(a)Cameron.local... >> * anders t [2010-06-27 13:34] [rec.sport.soccer]: >>> Do you think Maradona is already thinking about how to tackle Germany? >> He looked relaxed coming in, but when the game kicked off, he looked >> pretty nervous when he crossed himself. He's probably been a bit lax >> a couple of times as a player (90, 94). Not sure he'll make the same >> mistake as a manager. > > Mexico just blasted a long range shot against the crossbar. If Maradona > wasn't nervous, maybe he is a little now :-) > > But I think he knows better than underestimating Mexico. > > Btw, why is Argentina playing with blue, rather than black shorts? > > -- > Ll�o > > Anyone ever have an answer on why the blue shorts? I don't like them.
From: Myk Cameron on 5 Jul 2010 04:52 "Starcade" <darkstar7646(a)gmail.com> wrote in message news:b7a868e0-750b-485e-a935-8b3744ad836f(a)b33g2000prd.googlegroups.com... > >...with competent and respected officials like >there are in rugby... What the? You obviously don't read the rugby newsgroup. There is *at least* as much bitching there about refereeing as there is here. If not more. Myk
From: Insane Ranter on 5 Jul 2010 07:17
On Jun 28, 4:16 pm, JK <jkn...(a)oacpc.com> wrote: > Lléo wrote: > > "Sid" <sid(a)invalid_nerte.invalid.invalid_net.invalid> escreveu na mensagem > >news:slrni2f6hb.nl.sid(a)Cameron.local... > >> * anders t [2010-06-27 13:34] [rec.sport.soccer]: > >>> Do you think Maradona is already thinking about how to tackle Germany? > >> He looked relaxed coming in, but when the game kicked off, he looked > >> pretty nervous when he crossed himself. He's probably been a bit lax > >> a couple of times as a player (90, 94). Not sure he'll make the same > >> mistake as a manager. > > > Mexico just blasted a long range shot against the crossbar. If Maradona > > wasn't nervous, maybe he is a little now :-) > > > But I think he knows better than underestimating Mexico. > > > Btw, why is Argentina playing with blue, rather than black shorts? > > > -- > > Lléo > > Anyone ever have an answer on why the blue shorts? I don't like them. Maradona likes blue? |