From: FF on
Bruce D. Scott wrote:
> FF (FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com) wrote:
>
> : Lame. There's mistakes and there's mistakes. You can't compere
> : Schweini with Rafael in this respect. If you want to play what-if,
> : play it by the rules. :-)
> [...]
>
> My rules are as good as yours :-)

Not really. Mistakes like that of Schweini happen all the time and I
bet there were more of them in this match too, while the one of Rafael
obviously just shouldn't be made at such a level.

> BTW it was a totally deserved second yellow. Stupid play to do an
> intentional foul like that on the midfield line just because he's too
> lazy to run back.

Nobody's denying that. Not even SAF did, ugly as he was.
From: REDDEVIL6 on
On Mon, 12 Apr 2010 13:28:05 -0700 (PDT), FF
<FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com> wrote:

>Bruce D. Scott wrote:
>> FF (FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com) wrote:
>> : Sven Mischkies wrote:
>> : > Manx Gunner <goal(a)4thegunners!.com> wrote:
>> : >
>> : > > "They got him [Rafael] sent off, surrounding the referee... typical Germans."
>> : >
>> http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/blog/2010/apr/10/rafael-sending-off-schrodingers-cat
>> : >
>> : > ;)
>>
>> : Typical rubbish. Of course, Rafael being a hothead might very well
>> : have been sent off at some point, that's true (the only true bit). But
>> : the point is, if he had managed to keep his cool and stay in the game
>> : till near the end, from what we saw most likely United would have
>> : qualified. Nothing's for sure but it's fairly likely, that's how it
>> : goes in the alternate reality. You know, like my site, that's what
>> : prompted me to write this. (I know it's meant half as a joke but he's
>> : also serious, he thinks he's telling it as it is.)
>>
>>
>> Well, if you want to play what-if? then I suggest Bastian Schweinsteiger
>> at the beginning of the second half. Suppose he doesn't hesitate, he
>> remembers his Euro2008 form and takes the shot as soon as he gets open.
>> And scores. Then we don't need Rafael's sending off to "wonderfully
>> lose" the match and win the tie.
>>
>> Of course, in the real world, Schweini hesitated, then tried to push the
>> ball past one more defender, and lost it. Oh well.
>
>Lame. There's mistakes and there's mistakes. You can't compere
>Schweini with Rafael in this respect. If you want to play what-if,
>play it by the rules. :-)
>That said, I don't want to play what-if. IMO, because of the the
>thinness of the United squad (which has other deeper causes),
>Fergusson had to use players prone to many mistakes that don't belong
>to this level of the UCL. So, with a bit of bad luck, they lost. I was
>just countering the article above.

"other deeper causes" meaning injuries?

If so, you are correct!
From: FF on
REDDEV...(a)nospam.net wrote:
> On Mon, 12 Apr 2010 13:28:05 -0700 (PDT), FF
> <FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com> wrote:
>
> >Bruce D. Scott wrote:
> >> FF (FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com) wrote:
> >> : Sven Mischkies wrote:
> >> : > Manx Gunner <goal(a)4thegunners!.com> wrote:
> >> : >
> >> : > > "They got him [Rafael] sent off, surrounding the referee... typical Germans."
> >> : >
> >> http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/blog/2010/apr/10/rafael-sending-off-schrodingers-cat
> >> : >
> >> : > ;)
> >>
> >> : Typical rubbish. Of course, Rafael being a hothead might very well
> >> : have been sent off at some point, that's true (the only true bit). But
> >> : the point is, if he had managed to keep his cool and stay in the game
> >> : till near the end, from what we saw most likely United would have
> >> : qualified. Nothing's for sure but it's fairly likely, that's how it
> >> : goes in the alternate reality. You know, like my site, that's what
> >> : prompted me to write this. (I know it's meant half as a joke but he's
> >> : also serious, he thinks he's telling it as it is.)
> >>
> >>
> >> Well, if you want to play what-if? then I suggest Bastian Schweinsteiger
> >> at the beginning of the second half. Suppose he doesn't hesitate, he
> >> remembers his Euro2008 form and takes the shot as soon as he gets open.
> >> And scores. Then we don't need Rafael's sending off to "wonderfully
> >> lose" the match and win the tie.
> >>
> >> Of course, in the real world, Schweini hesitated, then tried to push the
> >> ball past one more defender, and lost it. Oh well.
> >
> >Lame. There's mistakes and there's mistakes. You can't compere
> >Schweini with Rafael in this respect. If you want to play what-if,
> >play it by the rules. :-)
> >That said, I don't want to play what-if. IMO, because of the the
> >thinness of the United squad (which has other deeper causes),
> >Fergusson had to use players prone to many mistakes that don't belong
> >to this level of the UCL. So, with a bit of bad luck, they lost. I was
> >just countering the article above.
>
> "other deeper causes" meaning injuries?
>
> If so, you are correct!

While we're at it, what was their complete injuries list at the time
of the game ?
From: MH on
FF wrote:
> REDDEV...(a)nospam.net wrote:
>> On Mon, 12 Apr 2010 13:28:05 -0700 (PDT), FF
>> <FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com> wrote:
>>
>>> Bruce D. Scott wrote:
>>>> FF (FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com) wrote:
>>>> : Sven Mischkies wrote:
>>>> : > Manx Gunner <goal(a)4thegunners!.com> wrote:
>>>> : >
>>>> : > > "They got him [Rafael] sent off, surrounding the referee... typical Germans."
>>>> : >
>>>> http://www.guardian.co.uk/football/blog/2010/apr/10/rafael-sending-off-schrodingers-cat
>>>> : >
>>>> : > ;)
>>>>
>>>> : Typical rubbish. Of course, Rafael being a hothead might very well
>>>> : have been sent off at some point, that's true (the only true bit). But
>>>> : the point is, if he had managed to keep his cool and stay in the game
>>>> : till near the end, from what we saw most likely United would have
>>>> : qualified. Nothing's for sure but it's fairly likely, that's how it
>>>> : goes in the alternate reality. You know, like my site, that's what
>>>> : prompted me to write this. (I know it's meant half as a joke but he's
>>>> : also serious, he thinks he's telling it as it is.)
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Well, if you want to play what-if? then I suggest Bastian Schweinsteiger
>>>> at the beginning of the second half. Suppose he doesn't hesitate, he
>>>> remembers his Euro2008 form and takes the shot as soon as he gets open.
>>>> And scores. Then we don't need Rafael's sending off to "wonderfully
>>>> lose" the match and win the tie.
>>>>
>>>> Of course, in the real world, Schweini hesitated, then tried to push the
>>>> ball past one more defender, and lost it. Oh well.
>>> Lame. There's mistakes and there's mistakes. You can't compere
>>> Schweini with Rafael in this respect. If you want to play what-if,
>>> play it by the rules. :-)
>>> That said, I don't want to play what-if. IMO, because of the the
>>> thinness of the United squad (which has other deeper causes),
>>> Fergusson had to use players prone to many mistakes that don't belong
>>> to this level of the UCL. So, with a bit of bad luck, they lost. I was
>>> just countering the article above.
>> "other deeper causes" meaning injuries?
>>
>> If so, you are correct!
>
> While we're at it, what was their complete injuries list at the time
> of the game ?

Hargreaves
Brown
Anderson
Rooney

Those are the main ones I can think of off hand. About the expected
number for this time of year. Eg. Arsenal has been missing Van Persie,
Fabregas, Gallas and a few others for a while - Vermaelen went down
today. Chelsea seem to have been quite fortunate with injuries this
year - Ashley Cole and Essien are the only major long term casualties I
can think of.
From: FF on
MH wrote:
> FF wrote:
> > REDDEV...(a)nospam.net wrote:
> >> On Mon, 12 Apr 2010 13:28:05 -0700 (PDT), FF
> >> <FAIRFOOTBALL.COM(a)domainsbyproxy.com> wrote:
> >>
> >>> That said, I don't want to play what-if. IMO, because of the the
> >>> thinness of the United squad (which has other deeper causes),
> >>> Fergusson had to use players prone to many mistakes that don't belong
> >>> to this level of the UCL. So, with a bit of bad luck, they lost. I was
> >>> just countering the article above.
> >> "other deeper causes" meaning injuries?
> >>
> >> If so, you are correct!
> >
> > While we're at it, what was their complete injuries list at the time
> > of the game ?
>
> Hargreaves
> Brown
> Anderson
> Rooney
>
> Those are the main ones I can think of off hand. About the expected
> number for this time of year.

My thoughts exactly. Not that impressive.
It certainly looks like they're way too dependent on the form of one
man, Rooney, since Ronaldo's departure.
First  |  Prev  |  Next  |  Last
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
Prev: MUFC v Bayern [R]
Next: Europa Leage [R]