From: Mirobaldo on 5 Aug 2010 18:07 Il 05/08/2010 12:32, Abubakr ha scritto: > On Aug 5, 8:11 pm, Mirobaldo<miroba...(a)yahoo.com> wrote: >> Il 03/08/2010 16:06, milivella ha scritto: >> >>> A match lasts until one of the teams leads by two goals. >> >>> Pros: >>> - A single error by the referee couldn't be decisive. >>> - Defensive/destructive tactics would be meaningless. >>> - The best team would have more chances to win. (but less upsets could >>> be considered bad by some) >> >>> Cons: >>> - Everything that depend from a unknown play time. (but sports like >>> volleyball and tennis live with it) >> >>> Your opinion? >> >> Min 30 minutes of game. >> Larger goal door. >> More player can be substitute. >> A substitution is not definitive. > > This just favours teams with depth in their squads and will only widen > the gulf between big and small clubs. This is possible, but I'm thinking of matches where the score still remain on 0-0 for 3-4 hours... Otherwise it's possible to end with 9-8 players on every team...
From: Insane Ranter on 5 Aug 2010 18:33 On Aug 5, 6:07 pm, Mirobaldo <miroba...(a)yahoo.com> wrote: > Il 05/08/2010 12:32, Abubakr ha scritto: > > > > > On Aug 5, 8:11 pm, Mirobaldo<miroba...(a)yahoo.com> wrote: > >> Il 03/08/2010 16:06, milivella ha scritto: > > >>> A match lasts until one of the teams leads by two goals. > > >>> Pros: > >>> - A single error by the referee couldn't be decisive. > >>> - Defensive/destructive tactics would be meaningless. > >>> - The best team would have more chances to win. (but less upsets could > >>> be considered bad by some) > > >>> Cons: > >>> - Everything that depend from a unknown play time. (but sports like > >>> volleyball and tennis live with it) > > >>> Your opinion? > > >> Min 30 minutes of game. > >> Larger goal door. > >> More player can be substitute. > >> A substitution is not definitive. > > > This just favours teams with depth in their squads and will only widen > > the gulf between big and small clubs. > > This is possible, but I'm thinking of matches where the score still > remain on 0-0 for 3-4 hours... > > Otherwise it's possible to end with 9-8 players on every team... just make the field smaller =)
From: milivella on 11 Aug 2010 08:45 Mirobaldo: > Il 03/08/2010 16:06,milivellaha scritto: > > > A match lasts until one of the teams leads by two goals. > > > Pros: > > - A single error by the referee couldn't be decisive. > > - Defensive/destructive tactics would be meaningless. > > - The best team would have more chances to win. (but less upsets could > > be considered bad by some) > > > Cons: > > - Everything that depend from a unknown play time. (but sports like > > volleyball and tennis live with it) > > > Your opinion? > > Min 30 minutes of game. > Larger goal door. > More player can be substitute. > A substitution is not definitive. # 1, 3 and 4 look like good patches to my proposal! Thanks. "Larger goal door"... I don't know, it sounds a bit like cutting a corner to me. -- Cheers milivella
From: milivella on 11 Aug 2010 08:47 Neil Gerace: > milivellawrote: > > A match lasts until one of the teams leads by two goals. > > According to the creation myth of Australian Rules football, the first game had a rule that the first team to score two > goals would win. The match lasted three afternoons and ended in a draw after only one goal had been scored. Oh, I didn't know. Thanks for sharing this story, that admittedly puts my proposal under a bad light! :) -- Cheers milivella
From: milivella on 11 Aug 2010 08:48 Insane Ranter: > What about making the field smaller by say 10yds to 20yds in length > maybe more might even smaller number of players. If anything watching > indoor, beach, or the smaller versions of the game we see more shots, > more goals, more action. With a 80yd pitch you'd still be far enough > that a shot from midfield is still kinda far to be taking but the > transition from offense to defense would be much faster. > > And play 9v9 so you could play say 3-3-2 or 3-4-1 etc. I'd really like to see how the game would be played. -- Cheers milivella
First
|
Prev
|
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 Prev: You can't buy the title! Next: Copa Libertadores 2010 tonight - Aug 3 |